Average Customer Review
4 out of 4 people found the following review helpful
I want to like this ink...
, August 11, 2012
I want to like this ink because the color is so beautiful. But the pearlescent
effect depends on some iridescent powder (or whatever) mixed in with the green
ink, and this pearly stuff just sinks to the bottom of the jar. the instructions
do say "shake well before using" but I shook verrrry well and the pearly stuff
remained in a sludgy layer at the bottom. I even stirred the ink from the bottom
up with a wooden coffee stirrer, but the pearly sludge only came up in a single
chunk that refused to disperse and did not mix with the green ink. I had a
little better luck getting the blue version of this ink to work, but Apple
Green and Coral both refused to cooperate.
I did try the improperly mixed inks with my dip nibs and it was very smooth & a
nice color...but without the pearlescent effect, its merely green ink :-/
3 out of 3 people found the following review helpful
Totally agree! The pearly...
, August 17, 2012
Totally agree! The pearly stuff just sinks to the bottom of the jar.
2 out of 2 people found the following review helpful
Like noted in the other...
, April 16, 2013
Like noted in the other two reviews the "pearlescent" was a goop at the bottom.
However even after I succesfully got it mixed with the ink I found it did not
want to write very well, by the time I had written three letters the ink stopped
flowing becasue the "pearlescent" part of the ink remained on the nib. Its very
pretty in the bottle and once it is on the paper. Far to time consuming to keep
If you are looking for...
, April 13, 2014
If you are looking for a good green dip pen ink - here is one! I really like the
color and even how it covers and flows at the first stroke.
Why then, for Heaven's sake, so low points?
I have to agree with other reviewers that as soon as we come to this special
Pearlescent part - you may easily face disappointment of various kinds. After
stirring or really shaking the ink to bring up the pearly part the flow through
nib changes, the smoothness of the ink varies and unfortunately, lowers.
I have very high opinion of Herbin inks for fountain pens. They really are
unique experience. Perhaps having seen their super quality on one line of
production the expected level in other lines is also raised compared to some
Summary - I will keep my green ink as I already paid for it and shipped it and
waited for it - lots of investments of different kinds, but I may alter my
future "favorite green" with something else. Again - as a green ink for a dip
pen it works just fine. Yes, buy. But if you expect some super lustrous sparkly
effects that were promised, it may become tricky to achieve.