Customer Reviews
Average Customer Review

(21 customer reviews)
13 out of 14 people found the following review helpful
A desk pen is not mobile...,
August 18, 2009
A desk pen is not mobile and must be kept upright at all times. Getting a nice
cup to hold the pen up in or the desk holder (available from Jetpens, too) is a
MUST. The cartridges seem a little pricey compared to normal fountain ink, but
there is where all comparisons end.
These pens write a fine line with excellent control. The tip writes fluidly and
can keep up with even fast writing. The ink is a nice, dark black (although not
as dark as some gel inks); it IS waterproof and the carbon will resist chemical
attack, as well. Please keep in mind that this IS a "waterdripping" pen that
relies on ink flow, gravity and a watery ink to work. This means that if you use
uncoated paper or thin, cheap paper, you WILL get some feathering and
bleedthrough. So be sure to pair this excellent pen with excellent paper to get
the most out of it.
This pen is pure joy to write with! I use mine daily and often. I write letters,
pen notes, make sketches and whatever else I can do just to feel the smooth nib
gliding across the paper.
I've used the Sailor desk pen, as well, and I can say that, in my opinion, both
pens have high quality. I prefer the Platinum ever so slightly (because of the
ink), but not by much.
As a quick warning: The carbon ink is NOT made for ordinary fountain pens. This
desk pen has a specially widened channel in the feed to accomodate the ink.
Putting the carbon ink in a normal pen risks clogging. PLEASE use the right ink
with the right pen with the right paper and you will NEVER be disappointed.
6 out of 6 people found the following review helpful
The Platinum Carbon pen...,
July 30, 2009
The Platinum Carbon pen allows you to use the waterproof Carbon Ink in a
fountain pen. After having used this pen for a while, I can recommend it.
I also own the Rotring Art Pen, which is a similar concept. The Rotring uses
typical fountain pen ink, which washes away with any water-based media (like
watercolor). I also found the Rotring to have flow issues (it was difficult to
get it started). If you left it unused for a while, forget about using it
without some maintenance.
The Carbon pen seems to address these issues. Plus, it's cheap. I don't think
you'll find a better deal on a waterproof ink-based sketching pen. I'm really
pleased with this find. Maybe now I can stop lugging bottles of ink with me when
I vacation!
5 out of 5 people found the following review helpful
This is a terrific pen....,
November 7, 2011
This is a terrific pen. The nib is super-fine, almost a needlepoint, but it
still manages to be much smoother than a nib of that size has a right to be.
This pen will work with regular bottled fountain pen ink, but it's really
designed to be used with Platinum's pigment-based carbon ink. This ink is
waterproof and will resist bleach and other chemicals commonly employed by check
forgers. The carbon ink is even more water-resistant than my other favorite,
Noodlers Bulletproof Black. (Unlike the Noodlers, the carbon ink doesn't leave a
layer of dye particles that washes away and smudges ever so slightly when the
paper gets wet.) For instantly waterproof lines, this is the ink to use.
The nib is a delight, really. The pen is super-responsive on just about any
paper. I find that I have more control with this pen than any other writing or
drawing instrument I own. It has rapidly become my favorite pen for writing and
sketching.
The cartridges will last a very long time--the nib is very sparing with ink, yet
it flows instantly and never skips. The only drawback to the carbon ink is the
fact that it thoroughly stains the plastic of the cartridge wall on the inside,
so it's just about impossible to see how much ink is left in the cartridge. But
I'm still on my first cartridge since buying the pen three weeks ago, and I
probably write 3-6 pages a day.
The pen holder for this pen is a handy way to keep this on your desk. It looks
nice and eliminates the need to uncap the pen before use. It's not strictly
necessary to keep this pen upright, though--I take it along with the cap when I
do work outside the house, and I've had it sitting in my bag for a day or two
over the weekend without drying up or hard starting.
A super pen for water-proof writing and drawing at a bargain price. If you like
super-fine nibs, you'll love this one. It feels good in the hand and is a joy to
use.
4 out of 4 people found the following review helpful
FANTASTIC PEN FOR COMIC...,
August 21, 2012
FANTASTIC PEN FOR COMIC BOOK DRAWING AND ILLUSTRATION! Handles very similar to--
if not exactly like-- the Sailor Desk Pen. Super-fine to medium lines are
possible. flexible for variable line work. Along with the Sailor, it has become
one of my favorite detailing pens.
4 out of 4 people found the following review helpful
I don't use this pen...,
April 25, 2012
I don't use this pen every day but have had it for quite a while. I decided
when then original cartridge was finished, I would buy the carbon ink. I still
am using the original cartridge. The line is so thin that the cartridge lasts a
long time. Some day I will get to buy the ink bottle. Anyway, my point is that
even though the cartridges may seem expensive, they last a long time.
1 out of 1 people found the following review helpful
This pen is exactly as...,
June 4, 2012
This pen is exactly as advertised and my clients really like it. Its fine point
is great for editing typescript. It does best with Carbon Ink, but writes well
with almost anything (Platinum Pigment ink, too). For a light pen, its really
well balanced, looks nice on my desk in its companion holder, cleans up nicely
and writes well even on cheap copy paper.
With respect to the guy who thought it wasn't so hot, Let's see, the pen costs
$13.50. You were expecting maybe a Montblanc Diplomat 149? (PS, carbon ink
works well in that pen, too).
1 out of 1 people found the following review helpful
I love this pen! I carry...,
January 30, 2012
I love this pen! I carry it everywhere with me in a pencil case, so far with no
mishaps. The only problem I had was when the ink in the cartridge neared
depletion, and a droplet of ink oozed out of the nib. That was messy, but
there's been no problem since I changed the cartridge and cleaned the nib.
Overall, this pen has given me hours of inspired writing and doodling!
1 out of 1 people found the following review helpful
Mon simple avis, une...,
May 28, 2011
Mon simple avis, une des meilleurs plumes pour le dessin, le crobard sur le vif
voir l'encrage BD, il glisse, extra fin, souple, débit d'encre constant mais
pas sans sensibilité et pour couronner le tout encre waterproof (carbon ink
cartouche) supporte la baignoire, l'aquarelle, la saison des pluies…
Bon, voilà je ne suis pas Rembrandt mais cet outil c'est sûr c'est une
merveille!
I have been carrying...,
May 2, 2013
I have been carrying this pen around with me for a couple of weeks. I'd call it
mobile! LOVE IT. It's become my go to pen, and I love the permanent ink. Good,
fine point.
LOVE the pen. But, I...,
April 1, 2013
LOVE the pen. But, I did have a bit of trouble with the ink. I had to fight
with it to get the ink to flow. Then it leaked and I used up the whole
cartridge in less than a week! Love the pen enough to buy some refills though.
I've had this pen over...,
February 9, 2013
I've had this pen over a year now, and it is the absolute best sketching pen for
use with watercolors I've tried. I've tried Lamy Safari, Platinum Preppy,
Noodler's Konrad, and Pilot Prera, and the Platinum Carbon Desk Pen is THE pen I
depend on for sketching when I will be using watercolors (which I do almost all
the time). The most important thing for me about this pen is its reliability.
Platinum Carbon ink (which is the best ink to hold fast against watercolors) may
be finicky and slow to start in other pens, but in this one it starts every time
and keeps going strong until the ink runs out. I also love the consistent
ultra-fine line.
As far as being a "desk pen", I don't use the desk holder (don't have one).
This pen doesn't need it. I kept this pen in my purse on a 3-month trip to
Australia (I was careful to keep it nib up, otherwise I did notice some leakage)
and it performed perfectly. While on that trip, I took a box of spare
cartridges but only needed to replace the cartridge once (and I drew with it
every day!). So this pen doesn't go through the ink that fast, which is nice
because the ink is expensive. While at home, I refill the cartridge with the
bottled version of Platinum Carbon ink using a syringe. I have a converter for
this pen but prefer to use the cartridge because I believe the ball inside the
cartridge helps keep the ink stirred. I love this pen so much, I have two; one
I keep in my purse and the other in my studio. This is my
"stuck-on-a-desert-island" pen, for sure!
The nib that I received...,
October 26, 2012
The nib that I received is very scratchy and it is practically unusable on copy
paper. Very regrettable because I like everything else about it. The nib will
make or break any pen.
I got the pen and the...,
August 15, 2012
I got the pen and the desk stand.
So nice to have a great pen on the ready at all times ... it means you can
sketch on everything!
As much as I like to be free and loose on big artwork I also really enjoy
working with a great instrument like this one. Great even ink delivery. Superb
fine line. Makes you think tight.
Highly recommend this one.
I bought this pen 6 months...,
July 5, 2012
I bought this pen 6 months ago and fell in love with it! At the same time I
bought the Sailor Desk Fountain Pen, extra fine which I also love. The two
pens are very similar both in body and performance and the differences are
slight but welcome.
I just received my latest order from JP and as usual I see that there will be at
least one or more "favorites" in the new bunch.
All the new pens reminded me of how happy I am with this great little pen, and
left me wondering why I hadn't just ordered a second one for use with other
colors.
Oh well, it gives me an excuse to place another order next month - or next week.
Light weight sketching...,
June 23, 2010
Light weight sketching tool with smooth and reliable performance. I had this pen
for a few months now, and it is always ready for an impromptu sketching session
starting right away without skipping. I do not use it everyday, but I keep it
stored pointing down on my drawing desk.
I was disappointed with...,
March 29, 2010
I was disappointed with this pen. It is made from a cheap black plastic and
feels it. The ink will not flow smoothly if you do not use the pen regularly
(i.e. every day). I have heard that this is an inherent problem arising from the
nature of the ink, and that the pen was designed to compensate for the
propensity of the ink to clog fountain pen systems (as opposed to dip style
pens), but apparently was not very successful. Word is that around the Platinum
offices, they hear this complaint often. The carbon ink is great. The pen, not
so great.
I agree with ratfactor....,
September 14, 2009
I agree with ratfactor. This pen has a fine, precise, responsive nib, allowing
loose sketching as well as very detailed drawing, and supplies a real waterproof
ink, i.e. one can go with watercolour over it without any graying. This pen
makes my profession as an illustrator easier. Thanks, Jetpens!
0 out of 1 people found the following review helpful
My new favorite. This...,
September 7, 2011
My new favorite. This pen has an elegant feel. It's the perfect shape for a pen.
1 out of 3 people found the following review helpful
I bought this pen because...,
September 5, 2011
I bought this pen because I was interested in fine Spencerian calligraphy. It is
definitely to wide and inflexible for this purpose. It's about this same as the
lamy safari extra fine and a hair thicker than the pilot desk pen. Beautiful
black ink though. Would much recommend the safari much more comfortable writing,
wonderful smooth nib without significant increase in width.
0 out of 1 people found the following review helpful
Wonderfull pen!!!!!!...,
September 27, 2010
Wonderfull pen!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
0 out of 1 people found the following review helpful
I just spent $300 on...,
July 20, 2010
I just spent $300 on fountain pens from these site, and I can say that I love
all of them, this one in particular. If you like extra-fine writing - this pen
is perfect for you.